Working Ideas

Unwritten Rule test

The Unwritten Rule test listens for a habit a health system follows without having decided to, and for what patients or staff long for that the habit keeps from them.

Question it answers

What do our patients and staff want that nobody has written down?

Every health system follows rules that appear in no policy manual. A new digital tool goes to everyone at once. Staff work at the top of their license. Patients get what the survey said they asked for. These habits usually work, which is why nobody questions them. When one stops working, patients and staff show it before they say it: they open the tool and leave, they build a workaround, or they stop calling. Behind that behavior is usually something they long for and have never put into words, such as being treated without judgment, being given time, or being heard.

A product built on that longing is one people choose to use. That is what a payer needs before it steers members toward a product, and what an employer needs before it offers one to its workforce.

How to use it

  1. Ask an AI tool what a health system like yours should do. Its answer is the most likely one, assembled from what every system in the category already does, which makes it the clearest written record of your unwritten rules. Pick the rule your patients or staff are already working around, the one most organizations file as an adoption problem.
  2. Go find the people that rule has failed. The patient who opened the app and closed it, the scheduler with a sticky-note system, the member who stopped calling. Surveys hear from the people a habit already serves, so these conversations happen in person, with nothing to sell and no script past "walk me through your day."
  3. Listen past the complaint for the longing under it. People can name what they are missing. Under it is usually a wish about how they are treated, to be unjudged, unhurried, or heard, that they have never said out loud. You have found it when it surprises your leadership team and the person who said it recognizes it, in one sentence of their own words.
  4. Open the story with the rule you changed. Confirm with compliance and clinical leadership that the change sits inside the walls, and decide whether the system will pay what it costs. Then lead with the habit you set aside, let the board, the payer, or the employer ask why, and answer in the patients' words. People repeat a story told in their own words, and those same words can carry the product to a payer's members and an employer's workforce.

In practice

Earlier in his career, Michael Alden rolled out a symptom-checking chatbot to many millions of people. People had told his team they wanted it, and few of them used it. When the team talked with people who had opened it and left, they heard fear. Some believed describing a symptom would raise their premiums. Others believed their doctor would judge what they had looked up. Neither was true, and no survey had shown it. What they longed for was a place to ask about a symptom without being judged, and the product had to earn that trust before it could help anyone.

At a primary care practice, front-desk staff were asked what they wanted from a service that would take on part of their work. Healthcare's habit points that kind of service at the easy calls, so staff can work at the top of their license. The staff wanted to keep the easy calls, which carry them through a day of hard ones, and to hand off the multi-step referrals and approvals that consume an afternoon. A service built on what they said takes on the hardest work and finishes it.

For a payer or an employer, the longing explains why people will use what the health system built. It belongs in the value case next to the numbers.

Where it breaks

Written rules stay put.
Regulation, accreditation, clinical standards, and contract terms sit outside the test. When a habit traces back to one of them, compliance and clinical leadership decide how to meet the requirement a better way.
Most habits deserve to stay.
A habit nobody is working around is doing its job.
A team can hear what it hopes to hear.
The recognition check in step three is the guard. When the people who said it do not recognize the sentence, keep listening.
Longing shows up slowly in the numbers.
A payer may want the claims result before it pays for the experience that produces it.
The test rests on a few cases.
We are still testing it with health system leaders.

What it borrows

  • Longing, from Carl Jung's description of an unconscious that holds what has not yet reached awareness (Psychological Types, 1921).
  • Positive deviance, which learns from the people whose behavior already departs from the norm (Pascale, Sternin, and Sternin, The Power of Positive Deviance, 2010).
  • Workarounds as evidence that a process does not fit the work (Debono and colleagues, BMC Health Services Research, 2013).